Auckland Council website.
This website has changed
This is the former Auckland City Council website, which has some of the information and services you need if you live or do business in the area. Go to the main Auckland Council website to access the complete range of council services.
Skip navigation
In this section
Plans, policies and reports
Plans, policies and reports

District plan - Isthmus section

Zoning street index | Planning maps | View protection maps | Appendices to maps | Text | Appendices to text | Annexures | Plan modifications | About the plan | Help | Home

Click here to view the Plan Changes and Modifications Index

Summary of Submissions: Plan Modification 209 - Private Plan Change

16 Rocklands Avenue and 178 Balmoral Road, Balmoral

Name No Decision Requested
Angus Wilson 1 Decline the private plan change
Fiona Sprott 4 Decline the private plan change 
Joanna Stone 5 Decline the private plan change 
Graham Fergusson 16 Decline the private plan change 
Balmoral Residents Rights Group Incoporated 21 Decline the private plan change 
Mark Gander and Johanna Gander 24 Decline the private plan change 
Nathan Inkpen and Sarah Kinniburgh 25 Decline the private plan change 
Malcolm Butler 26 Decline the private plan change 
Nick Frakes 27 Decline the private plan change 
Sandra Frakes 28 Decline the private plan change 
Balmoral Community Group. 30 Decline the private plan change 
Sue Duncan 31 Decline the private plan change 
Bruce Duncan 32 Decline the private plan change 
Olivia Tringham 33 Decline the private plan change 
Angela Long 34 Decline the private plan change 
Barbara Lloyd 35 Decline the private plan change 
Peter McNoe 36 Decline the private plan change 
Leslie Trimnell 38 Decline the private plan change 
Rhoda Slater 39 Decline the private plan change 
Susie Barrington 40 Decline the private plan change 
Robyn Cossar and Bryan Cossar 41 Decline the private plan change 
Niall Robertson and Mary Robertson 42 Decline the private plan change 
David Stringer 43 Decline the private plan change
Helen Parker 44 Decline the private plan change 
Murray Speight 45 Decline the private plan change 
Vivienne Hogan and Chris Naughton 46 Decline the private plan change 
Carol O'Brien 47 Decline the private plan change 
Lloyd O'Brien 48 Decline the private plan change 
Lynne French 49 Decline the private plan change
Neil Ridgway 50 Decline the private plan change 
Derek Townsend 51 Decline the private plan change 
Vetsi Neelakantapillai 52 Decline the private plan change 
Lillian Epston and David Epston 53 Decline the private plan change 
Trevor Weaver 57 Decline the private plan change 
Diana Winks 61 Decline the private plan change 
Donna Steel and Gavin Parratt 62 Decline the private plan change 
Geraldine Taylor 63 Decline the private plan change 
Peter Stephenson 64 Decline the private plan change 
Michael Care and Heather Care 65 Decline the private plan change 
Christina Hawkins 66 Decline the private plan change 
Toni Horne 67 Decline the private plan change 
Stephen Costello and Ann Marie Costello 68 Decline the private plan change 
David Anderson and Jean Anderson 69 Decline the private plan change 
Michael Roberts 70 Decline the private plan change 
Anthony Tringham 71 Decline the private plan change 
Max Tringham 72 Decline the private plan change 
Wei –Tei Tsai 73 Decline the private plan change 
Belinda Wilson 74 Decline the private plan change 
Domanik Nola 75 Decline the private plan change 
Christine Chapman 76 Decline the private plan change 
Vivienne Nickles 77 Decline the private plan change 
Helen Kidd, Robert Kidd and Jamie Kidd 78 Decline the private plan change 
Maike Wolbers and Ron Jacob 79 Decline the private plan change 
Desmond Davenport and Irene Davenport 80 Decline the private plan change 
Anne Mikhailiadis 81 Decline the private plan change 
Rolf Poelman 82 Decline the private plan change 
Cleone Campbell 83 Decline the private plan change 
Carmel McKeown 84 Decline the private plan change 
Beverley Roser 85 Decline the private plan change 
James Walsh and Kathleen Walsh 86 Decline the private plan change
Ann-Marie Grindlay 87 Decline the private plan change 
Bryce Marsden 88 Decline the private plan change 
Philippa Grey 89 Decline the private plan change 
Brian Cater and June Cater 90 Decline the private plan change 
Sharon Cooper 91 Decline the private plan change 
Daniel Marshall 92 Decline the private plan change 
Marion Dodd 93 Decline the private plan change 
George Dodd 94 Decline the private plan change 
Linda Waters 95 Decline the private plan change 
Nicola Marsden 96 Decline the private plan change 
Michelle Wood 97 Decline the private plan change 
Geoffrey Tune 98 Decline the private plan change 
Charles Spillane and Jenny Spillane 99 Decline the private plan change 
Mitch Mitchell 100 Decline the private plan change 
Erin Prior and Phil Prior 101 Decline the private plan change 
Michael Grimwood (late submission) 104 Decline the private plan change 
Kathy Cook and Lionel Cook (late submission) 105 Decline the private plan change 
Raymond McVinnie 106 Decline the private plan change 
Jennifer Maidment 107 Decline the private plan change 
Robert Wilson (late submission) 110 Decline the private plan change 
Linda Sluyter (late submission) 111 Decline the private plan change 
Glen Cooper (late submission) 112 Decline the private plan change 
Bruce Gulley 2 Decline the rezoning of 16 Rocklands Avenue from Residential 6a to Business 2.
Marjet Pot 9 Decline the rezoning of 16 Rocklands Avenue from Residential 6a to Business 2.  
Jane Dudley 10 Decline the rezoning of 16 Rocklands Avenue from Residential 6a to Business 2.  
Nicholas Foster 3 Accept the private plan change
Ann Winn 8 Accept the private plan change 
Kristen Leys 6 Decline the plan modification
David Bulmer 7 Decline the plan modification  
Christine Thomas 18 Decline the plan modification  
Margaret Hyland 19 Decline the plan modification  
Dr Brett Ogilvie 20 Decline the plan modification
The Albert-Eden-Roskill Ratepayers and Residents Association 11 Decline the application entirely.
Dr Peter Boys 12 Decline the application entirely.

Hold a public hearing.
The Auckland Council Ratepayers Association 13 That the council reject the application its entirety.
Hon Phil Goff. MP for Mt Roskill 14 Residents are generally concerned about the sheer scale of commercial enterprises encroaching upon well established residential communities and I urge Council to consider these matters and the submissions of residents when they determine the zoning application.
Vera Wrassky 15 Not permit zone change. Use residential area for high density housing/pensioner flats at 178 Balmoral Road 2(b) and leave 16 Rockland Avenue.
Manoo Ala'i 17 Accept with amendments

It is submitted that the applicant should be able to (and required by Council to) devise a traffic management plan that does not rely on having 16 Rocklands Ave as a main vehicle access point.

At a minimum the applicant must at least analyse and show alternative access point options that do not rely on rezoning 16 Rocklands Avenue.

The plan modification should be declined as far as it includes the lot at 16 Rocklands Avenue, or at a minimum there must be provision made to ensure that there can be no new vehicular access/exit point at 16 Rocklands Avenue.
Paul Mabus 22 Decline the proposal . The site at 16 Rocklands Avenue should remain zoned as Residential 6a.
Lisa Chandler 23  
Nick Frakes and Sandra Frakes 29 That the Council decline the application.
Anne Ridgway 37 Oppose in part - 16 Rocklands Avenue, Balmoral - the plan change.
Trevor Weaver 54 Oppose the plan modification. No decision requested
Trevor Weaver 55/1 Decline the plan modification for 16 Rocklands Avenue
Elizabeth Donaldson 58/1 Decline the plan modification for 16 Rocklands Avenue  
Suzanne Weaver 59/1 Decline the plan modification for 16 Rocklands Avenue
Trevor Weaver 55/2 Accept with amendments the plan modification for 178 Balmoral Road.
Elizabeth Donaldson 58/2 Accept with amendments the plan modification for 178 Balmoral Road.
Suzanne Weaver 59/2 Accept with amendments the plan modification for 178 Balmoral Road.  
Ruby Lordan 56/1 Decline the plan modification for 16 Rocklands Avenue
Val Hawkins 60/1 Decline the plan modification for 16 Rocklands Avenue 
Ruby Lordan 56/2 Decline the plan modification for 178 Balmoral Road.
Val Hawkins 60/2 Decline the plan modification for 178 Balmoral Road. 
NZ Transport Agency 102/1 That the application be deferred or declined unless:

Further information is provided to address the issues identified in sections 9 to 12 [of the submission] or appropriate provisions are agreed between all relevant parties, to avoid, remedy, or mitigate adverse effects on the surrounding and wider transport network.
Shona Wilkinson 103 Decline the plan modification
Carol Smith and Wes Smith 108 Decline the plan modification  
Helen Goldsworthy and Ivan Goldsworthy 109 Decline the plan modification  

 

The copies of submissions are in Portable Document Files (PDFs) for which you will need Adobe Acrobat Reader. If you do not already have the free Acrobat Reader software you will need to download it before you can view and print these documents.