Council member and meetings
MINUTES OF A MEETING OF THE
PLANNING AND REGULATORY COMMITTEE HELD ON THURSDAY, 8 DECEMBER 2005 AT 9.30 AM
| PRESENT: |
Councillors: |
Glenda |
Fryer |
[Chair] |
|
|
Neil |
Abel |
|
|
|
Doug |
Armstrong, QSO |
[From 9.36am Item 6] |
|
|
Dr Cathy |
Casey |
[Until 10.40am Item 10] |
|
|
Christine |
Caughey |
[From 10.10am item 9] |
|
|
Bill |
Christian, JP |
|
|
|
Toni |
Millar, JP |
|
|
|
Graeme |
Mulholland, JP |
[From 11.05am Item C1] |
|
|
Noelene |
Raffills |
|
|
|
Penny |
Sefuiva |
[from 9.41am Item 6] |
|
|
Faye |
Storer |
[Until 9.42am Item 6] From 9.55am Item 8] |
APOLOGIES
That the apologies from Cr Mulholland and Cr Caughey for lateness be
accepted.
CARRIED
CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES
That the minutes of the Planning and Regulatory Committee meeting held on
Thursday, 23 November 2005 be confirmed as a true and correct record.
CARRIED
EXTRAORDINARY BUSINESS
In order to meet the timeframes for the legal process of a temporary liquor
ban, this matter will need to be dealt with as an extraordinary item at this
meeting because it is the last time the committee meets before the liquor ban
period.
3.1 TEMPORARY LIQUOR BANS WAIHEKE ISLAND 2005/06
- That a temporary liquor ban be put in place daily from 2100
hours to 0600 hours, between 23 December 2005 and 2 January 2006 inclusive for
the following areas on Waiheke Island;
- for the entire length of the following beaches,
including foreshore and reserve area of:
- Onetangi Beach;
- Palm Beach;
-
Oneroa Beach;
- Little Oneroa Beach;
-
Blackpool Beach;
- Surfdale Beach;
-
Mary Wilson Reserve;
- Omiha Beach;
-
Rocky Bay Beach;
- Sandy Bay Beach;
-
Shelly Beach;
- the following streets in Onetangi;
- the Strand between First Avenue and Fourth Avenue;
-
third Avenue from the junction of Waiheke Road to The Strand;
-
Fourth Avenue from the junction of Waiheke and Onetangi Roads to
The Strand;
- in addition;
- Oceanview Road from the wharf at Matiatia to the junction with
Puriri Road including the Beach access ways from Oceanview Road to Beach Parade
in Oneroa.
That all liquor ban reports for October-January 2006/07 be
provided to the committee by August 2006 for consideration.
CARRIED
PUBLIC FORUM
4.1 UNLAWFUL REMOVAL OF POHUTUKAWA TREE
That the apology of Mr G B Shaw for the unlawful removal of a Pohutukawa
tree at 21 Mt Smart Road be noted.
CARRIED
REPORTS REQUESTED/PENDING
That the reports requested/pending information from the Hearings Services
Manager for the month of December 2005 be received.
CARRIED
CENTRAL AREA MINIMUM RESIDENTIAL APARTMENT STANDARDS
- That the report entitled "Minimum Standards for Residential
Apartments in Central Auckland" by Clinton Bird, dated November 2005 provide the
basis for Council officers' further discussions on the subject with the
Department of Building and Housing and an Auckland Regional Council
inter-council working group.
- That the report entitled ""Minimum Standards for Residential
Apartments in Central Auckland" by Clinton Bird, dated November 2005 and its
recommendations be ' and reported to the committee once decisions on submissions
to Plan Changes 1 and 2 have been made and the Auckland Regional Council
inter-council group process is completed.
- That officers consider whether a joint regional approach on
apartment standards is appropriate, pending outcomes of the inter-council
working group.
CARRIED
ANIMAL CONTROL ENFORCEMENT
That Clare Connell, Animal Contracts Manager, be thanked for her verbal
report on training provided for animal control services staff.
CARRIED
BYLAW AND DISTRICT PLAN COMPLIANCE PROJECTS
That the committee requests the Works and Services Committee
consider initiating a trial for an holistic rubbish collection system in
suburban shopping centres.
CARRIED
DISTRICT PLAN CHANGES FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
- That the District Plan Changes For Affordable Housing issue be
referred to the Urban Strategy and Governance Committee for their consideration
and a request that it be a recommendation to the Annual Plan Direction Setting
meeting that funding provision be made for the investigation and implementation
of a regulatory approach to providing affordable housing in new developments.
Secretarial Note: That to provide for this approach, the
investigation would need to consider any changes in legislation that may be
required and the funding sought is essentially for this investigation.
- That previous investigative work on inclusionary zoning be
tabled at the Urban Strategy and Governance Committee.
CARRIED
A division was called for, voting on which was as follows:
| For the Motion: |
Against the Motion: |
| Cr Neil Abel Cr Dr Cathy Casey
Cr Christine Caughey
Cr Faye Storer
Cr Glenda Fryer
Cr Penny Sefuiva |
Cr Doug Armstrong Cr Bill Christian
Cr Toni Millar
Cr Noelene Raffills |
Deputy Mayor Dr Bruce Hucker, Cr Graeme Mulholland and His Worship the Mayor
were absent.
The motion was declared CARRIED by 6 votes to 4.
ISSUES FOR REVIEW OF SIGNS AND BILLBOARD BYLAWS
That the committee appoints a working party of Cr Fryer, Cr
Storer, Cr Caughey, Cr Mulholland and Cr Sefuiva to work with staff to develop
appropriate visual parameters and to assess the need for saving provisions, for
the reviews of the Signs and Billboards bylaws.
CARRIED
Item 7 was taken at this time.
LIQUOR BAN FOR COCA COLA CHRISTMAS IN THE PARK
- That a temporary liquor ban be put in place for the 2005
Christmas in the Park event on 10 December 2005 (including the nominated rain
date of 11 December 2005) to cover from 1700 hours until 2400 hours.
- That all liquor ban reports for October-January
2006/07 be provided to the committee by August 2006 for consideration.
CARRIED
LANDOWNER CONSENT FOR AN AIRSPACE LICENCE OVER ROAD RESERVE:
312-330 BROADWAY, NEWMARKET
That the Laneowner Consent For An Airspace Licence Over Road Reserve
312-330 Broadway, Newmarket application be withdrawn from the agenda due to the
proposal being redesigned.
CARRIED
PLAN CHANGE 164 BUSINESS 8 ZONING FOR COCA-COLA AMATIL (NZ) LTD,
THE OASIS, MT WELLINGTON
That the committee recommend to the full council:
- That plan change 164 (applying a business 8 zoning and associated
concept plan to approximately 8.4ha of land at The Oasis, Mt Wellington, for
Coca-Cola Amatil Ltd) be approved and incorporated into the Auckland City
District Plan: Isthmus Section 1999.
- That the Manager: Isthmus and Islands Resource Management be authorised
to publicly notify the date on which plan change 164 will become operative.
CARRIED
APPOINTMENT OF COMMISSIONERS
14.1. PLAN MODIFICATION 10, ALEXANDRA PARK
That Independent Commissioner G Hill (Chairman), Cr Caughey, Cr Fryer,
Board Member K Carter, (and alternates Cr Mulholland and Cr Storer) be appointed
to hear submissions and make a recommendation to Council on Plan Modification
10, relating to Alexandra Park which seeks to introduce a new concept plan
(E09-55) and business 8 zoning to a 2.36 ha portion of the site currently used
for carparking fronting Green Lane West.
CARRIED
14.2. PLAN CHANGE 183
That Cr Caughey (Chairman), Cr Storer, Cr Mulholland and Board Member K
Carter (and alternate Independent Commissioner R Wright) be appointed to hear
submissions and make a recommendation to Council on Plan Change 183 which amends
the Auckland District Plan: Isthmus Section to include four buildings as
scheduled heritage items in the Plan being 2-8 Osborne Street, Newmarket (Kents
Bakery), 481-487 Khyber Pass Road, Newmarket (Kents Building), 586-592 Remuera
Rd, Remuera (McLaren Service Station) and 2 Stanley Street, Parnell (Swan
Hotel).
CARRIED
14.3. PLAN CHANGE 184
That Cr Caughey (Chairman), Cr Fryer, Cr Mulholland, (and alternates
Independent Commissioner R Wright and Board Member L Rea) be appointed to hear
submissions and make a recommendation to council on Plan Change 184 which amends
the Auckland District Plan: Isthmus Section to include one building as a
scheduled heritage item in the Plan. The proposed plan change is for scheduling
the building at 42 St Stephens Avenue, "Paykel House".
CARRIED
COMMUNITY TREE CARE COURSE
That Councillors and Community Board tree representatives who have not
attended the Community Tree Care Course be given the opportunity to attend the
course in 2006.
CARRIED
EXCLUSION OF THE PUBLIC : LOCAL GOVERNMENT OFFICIAL INFORMATION AND MEETINGS ACT 1987
That the public be excluded from the following part(s) of the proceedings
of this meeting.
The general subject of each matter to be considered while the public is
excluded, the reason for passing this resolution in relation to each matter, and
the specific grounds under Section 48(1) of the Local Government Official
Information and Meetings Act 1987 for the passing of this resolution are as
follows:
| Item No. |
General subject of each matter to be
considered |
Reason for passing this resolution in
relation to each matter |
Ground(s) under section 48(1) for the
passing of this resolution |
| C1. |
Auckland City District Plan: Isthmus
Section Plan Modification 90A Network Utilities. |
Good Reason to withhold exists under
section 7 |
Section 48(1)(a) |
| C2. |
Animal Shelter Report |
Good Reason to withhold exists under
section 7 |
Section 48(1)(a) |
This resolution is made in reliance on Section 48(1)(a) of the Local
Government Official Information and Meetings Act 1987 and the particular
interest or interests protected by section 6 or section 7 of that Act which
would be prejudiced by the holding of the whole or relevant part of the
proceedings of the meeting in public are as follows:
| Item No. |
Reason to withhold information under
section 7 |
|
| C1. |
That a right of appeal lies to the
Environment Court against the final decision of the Committee |
[Section 48.2(a)(i)] |
| C2. |
To enable the Council to carry out,
without prejudice or disadvantage, commercial activities. |
[Section 7(2)(h)] |
CARRIED
Item 3.1 was taken at this time.
There being no further business the Chairman declared the meeting closed at
11.45am.